BBC Shamelessly Mis-Reports Archbishop of Westminster...

Picture (left): A selection of 'attractive' condoms...

I think the Archbishop's words may have been taken out of context, but for someone who was meant to be so 'media savvy', this is hardly a positive news story. Somehow a story about contraception still manages to get back onto child abuse while still perpetuating the slur against the Holy Father, despite confirmation that he was not guilty of wrongdoing from the man in charge of the Church's trial against Fr Murphy and...and Catherine Pepinster of The Tablet manages to sneek in to sing an ode to the sheath!

Can you imagine a worse news story?! I would expect some kind of reappraisal of this shoddy, misleading reporting of his words from the Archbishop of Westminster, but if it doesn't arrive, we should be more than a little concerned!

Lifted from the BBC News website:

The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Westminster has said he understands why contraception is seen as "attractive" in tackling Third World poverty. But Archbishop Vincent Nichols told BBC WM it was not the Church's role to add to calls for condom distribution. The Church opposes contraception, because it believes it interferes with the creation of life.

Aid agencies say contraception is an important way for women in developing nations to take control of fertility. Any form of birth control that might interfere with conception, such as condoms or the Pill, is regarded as sinful by the Catholic Church.

The Church also argues that, in any case, all children should be welcomed as a gift from God. Asked by BBC WM how Catholic teaching could continue to discourage contraception in poorer parts of the world where the birth rate was rapidly rising, Archbishop Nichols said: "I think when it comes to Third World poverty and the great pressure under which many women are put by men, I can see the arguments, why, in the short term, [the] means that give women protection are attractive."

Child abuse (Eh?!)

He went on to say that longer term solutions were needed, and as there were already plenty of "champions" of condoms, it was not the role of the Church to add its voice to those. "If we solve the poverty, then consistently we know that the birth rate comes down. If we provide people with security, then consistently birth rates will come down. And they're the radical issues that we should be addressing, not short-term intrusive fixes."

The editor of Catholic publication The Tablet said there had been a "softening" of language from some senior clergy regarding contraception. But Catherine Pepinster also told BBC Radio 4's Today programme it was hard to tell if that would result in a change in policy. There were some cardinals and theologians who said using a condom to prevent HIV, a situation when "you're concerned with preserving life and avoiding death... is a good thing", she added. (So much for new 'Catholic Voices' defending the Church!)

In his interview the Archbishop also talked about the child sex abuse scandal currently confronting the Church worldwide. Allegations that children have been molested by priests have been growing for years. Now Pope Benedict XVI has been drawn into the controversy, with critics saying that he failed to investigate an abusive US priest, Fr Lawrence Murphy.

Victims say that Father Murphy may have abused up to 200 boys with hearing impairments. Archbishop Nichols, who admitted on the Andrew Marr show recently that the Church in England and Wales had had its own share of abuse allegations, said that there had been a breakdown in trust across many institutions in Britain, such as politics and the finance industry, as well as the Church.

Despite the Church in England and Wales taking realistic and thorough steps, there also had to be an "honesty and an openness" about what had gone wrong and a search for higher moral standards. "Our crisis has been real, our addressing it is real, and I think it's repeated, or seen in an echo, in other very important parts of society at the moment. We have a lot to do until we get back as a society to the point where we relate to each other on an assumption of trustworthiness."


gemoftheocean said…
I just saw that story up prominently too. I can think of a few people who deserve a good neck wringing. Not all of whom belong to the well deserving media...
Patricius said…
The headline they give is simply NOT justified even by the words quoted. It is, as you say, shameless mis-reporting. For the Adchbishop to say that he can see that condoms might seem to provide an attractive solution is to say no more than to say that sin often seems attractive. If it were not we would all be perfect. Thanks for highlighting this appalling BBC abuse.
Ben Trovato said…
Did you hear Pepinster recant an hour later?

georgem said…
The Daily Telegraph headlined the "new" softer line on contraception. Guess they all used the same agency story without double-checking. It's developing into an unfortunate media habit.
What exactly does he say about condoms though? Exactly...?

Popular posts from this blog

So Now That We're All Saying What We're Thinking...